Insurance expert Jon Whiteley on M&A trends
Insurance mergers and acquisitions remain active, but buyers are growing more selective, prioritizing businesses with recurring revenue, strong client retention, and clear growth potential over sheer scale.
Jon Whiteley, director of insurance M&A at Capital & Trust, said the market is still drawing interest from private equity-backed consolidators and strategic acquirers looking to expand into niche markets. However, the focus has shifted toward operational resilience and sustainable growth.
Valuations hold steady for quality businesses
Valuations for well-run insurance firms are not only holding but, in some cases, increasing. Whiteley noted that while buyers are conducting more thorough due diligence than in previous years, there remains significant capital available for businesses that meet their criteria.
Firms with diversified income streams, robust compliance, loyal client bases, and a compelling growth narrative tend to secure the strongest valuations. When risks surface during due diligence, buyers are more likely to adjust deal structures—through earn-outs or deferred payments—rather than slash the headline price.
Related: Commercial Combined’s Wild West Era Ends at Roundtable
One overlooked issue, according to Whiteley, is the lack of preparation. Buyers often uncover problems during due diligence, such as gaps in compliance, poor client documentation, or weak data quality. These can delay deals or reduce their value.
“The best way to avoid this is early planning,” he said. “Ensuring financial, legal, and regulatory records are in order before entering the market can make the process smoother and inspire confidence.”
Preparation as a competitive advantage
Capital & Trust has expanded its role beyond simply sourcing deals. The firm now works with clients well before they decide to sell, helping them assess value, prepare their business, identify suitable buyers, and manage a competitive sale process.
“We’re focused on achieving the best long-term outcome, not just closing a deal,” Whiteley said. “Preparation and strategic positioning are where we add the most value.”
Related: Bamboo expands Greenshoots facility to $175m
The firm’s approach combines sector expertise with strong buyer relationships, aiming to maximize outcomes for sellers. This shift reflects broader market trends, where buyers increasingly favor businesses that can demonstrate operational efficiency and regulatory compliance.
Looking ahead, Whiteley expects insurance M&A to remain strong, driven by the sector’s resilient revenue streams and fragmented market. Buyers will likely place even greater emphasis on technology, data, and operational efficiency, while regulatory scrutiny will continue to shape deal structures.
For owners considering a sale in the next few years, Whiteley’s advice is clear: start preparing now. “Well-managed businesses with strong fundamentals will continue to attract significant interest,” he said. “The earlier you begin, the better positioned you’ll be.”
That preparation could mean the difference between a smooth transaction and one fraught with delays—or worse, a deal that falls apart entirely. And in a market where buyers are pickier than ever, that edge matters.
